Short answer: To decide whether to repair or replace a dishwasher, use the 50% rule: repair when the written quote is under half the installed price of a comparable new one and the dishwasher is under about 10 years old. A latch, drain pump, inlet valve or heating element costs $160–$380 in Los Angeles and usually passes. A rusted tub or two major parts on an old machine usually doesn't.

Repair or replace? Run your numbers

This guide is for homeowners and landlords in Los Angeles, Orange and Ventura counties who have a dishwasher quote in hand, or a dishwasher that has started acting its age. It gives the rule we use on service calls, our prices by part, and the cases where we tell people to put the money toward a new one.

Should you repair or replace a dishwasher? The 50% rule

Repair when the written quote is less than half the installed price of a comparable new dishwasher and the machine has life left. A mainstream dishwasher lasts roughly 10–12 years; hard water and heavy daily use pull that down, and good care pushes it up.

"Installed price" is the honest comparison: the new dishwasher plus delivery, installation, a new supply line and haul-away of the old one, and any cabinet or countertop work if the new one doesn't fit the old opening. "Comparable" means like for like: a quiet stainless-tub model against the same, not against the cheapest one in the store. The calculator on this page runs the numbers for you.

Which dishwasher repairs are worth it?

Most of them, because most dishwasher failures are one part. Typical prices in Los Angeles, parts and labor included:

RepairWhat you noticeTypical LA priceUsually worth it?
Door latch or switchWon't start; lights on, no response$160–$290Yes
Drain pumpWater standing in the bottom after a cycle$190–$330Yes
Inlet valve or float switchWon't fill, overfills or drips into the tub$170–$300Yes
Heating elementDishes cool and wet after a heated-dry cycle$220–$380Yes
Wash pump or circulation motorFills and drains but doesn't spray; dishes dirty$280–$520Yes under about 8 years; weigh it after that
Control boardDead or erratic controls with good power$260–$560Yes if the machine has years left

Before paying for any of these, rule out the free fixes: a clogged filter, a blocked air gap or disposal connection, an empty rinse-aid dispenser. Our guides to a dishwasher not draining and a dishwasher that won't start list them in order.

When should you replace a dishwasher instead?

Four situations where we usually recommend replacement:

  1. The tub or door liner is rusted through or cracked. A leak from the tub itself isn't a part you can swap, and water under a dishwasher damages cabinets and floors quietly.
  2. Two major parts at once on an older machine. A control board plus a wash pump on a 10-year-old dishwasher adds up past the 50% line, and the next part isn't far behind.
  3. The racks are rusted and shedding coating on a machine that also needs a repair. Rust spots transfer to dishes, and new racks added to a repair bill change the math.
  4. It's past about 10–12 years and the repair is more than a single small part. A latch on an old dishwasher is fine. A pump or board is money that should go toward the next one.

Age alone isn't a reason. A 12-year-old dishwasher that needs a $200 drain pump and otherwise cleans well is still a good repair.

Do panel-ready and premium dishwashers follow different math?

Yes. A panel-ready or premium dishwasher from Miele, Bosch's upper lines, Thermador or Cove costs several times what a mainstream model does, and replacing it can mean refitting a custom cabinet panel. Under the same 50% rule, repairs that wouldn't make sense on a basic machine, a circulation pump or a control board, usually do on these, well into their second decade. Parts sometimes have to be ordered, which can mean a second visit. We're independent, not a factory service center for any brand, and use OEM parts whenever they're available; see our Bosch repair page for what we see on those models.

What about rental units?

For landlords and property managers the rule is the same, with two additions. Count the cost of a second trip and a tenant without a dishwasher when comparing, and standardize: if a building's dishwashers are all the same age and model, the third control board is a signal to plan replacements at turnover instead of repairing one at a time.

How do you decide in one visit?

Book the diagnostic and ask for three things in writing: the failed part, the price to fix it, and anything else the technician sees coming, such as a rusting rack or a seeping pump seal. The dishwasher diagnostic is $69, and it's applied to the repair you approve or to installing a replacement, so you don't pay it on top. If the repair isn't worth it, we'll say so.

Call (866) 696-7767 or book online. Calls placed before noon are usually seen the same day across Los Angeles, Orange and Ventura counties, Irvine included, with no travel charge. What we check is on our dishwasher repair page.

Frequently asked questions

Is it worth repairing a 10-year-old dishwasher?

It depends on the part. A door latch, drain pump or inlet valve at $160–$330 is usually still worth it if the dishwasher cleans well and the tub and racks are sound. A wash pump or control board on a 10-year-old mainstream dishwasher usually isn't, because the machine is near the end of its 10–12-year life.

How long should a dishwasher last?

A mainstream dishwasher typically lasts about 10–12 years. Hard water, daily heavy use and a clogged filter shorten that; rinse aid, a clean filter and hot incoming water help. Premium and panel-ready models are built to last longer and are usually worth repairing into their second decade.

What is the most expensive dishwasher repair?

On mainstream models, the wash pump or circulation motor ($280–$520 in Los Angeles) and the control board ($260–$560). Either one alone can be worth doing on a newer machine. Both together on an old one usually means replacement is the better value.

Is the diagnostic fee wasted if I decide to replace the dishwasher?

No. The $69 diagnostic is applied to the repair you approve or to installing a replacement, and it buys a written answer about what failed and what else is wearing out. If you decline both, the diagnostic is all you pay.

Repair or replace?

Our rule of thumb: repair when the quote is under half the installed price of a comparable new one and the appliance has life left. Try your numbers.

Typical: drain pump $190–$330. Use your written quote if you have one.

Repair when the quote is under half the price of a new one and the appliance has life left — typically 10–12 years for a dishwasher.

Rough installed prices and typical lifespans from our technicians' experience, the brand notes on this site and NAHB's study of home-component life expectancy. A written quote and a real price on a new unit beat any estimate — and if a repair isn't worth it, we'll tell you.

Not sure whether to repair it? Book the diagnostic and decide with real numbers.

$69 dishwasher diagnostic, applied to the repair or to a replacement installation. Written quote before any work.

Emanuel “Manny” MisayeledisOwner of Pros Fix Appliances in Glendale (California BHGS registration A49955). Repairs residential and built-in appliances across Los Angeles, Orange and Ventura counties, including the luxury residences and senior-living communities the company services.